Former HCPD deputy chief, Brandon Strickland, faces arraignment as Spivey case turns criminal

Posted

Brandon Strickland is due in a Kershaw County courtroom later today, Thursday, one day after a grand jury indicted Weldon Boyd and Bradley Williams on murder charges in the 2023 killing of Scott Spivey.

Nov 19, 2026 · Developing story https://x.com/myrtlebeachnews

For more than three years, the official account of Scott Spivey’s death on Camp Swamp Road was self-defense. This week, that account gave way on two fronts at once.

On Wednesday, a grand jury returned indictments charging North Myrtle Beach businessman Weldon Boyd and his passenger, Kenneth “Bradley” Williams, with murder and possession of a weapon during a violent crime, according to the Horry County Clerk of Court’s Office. Then came a second development: Brandon Strickland, who was Horry County Police Department’s deputy chief when Spivey died, is scheduled to be arraigned at 2 p.m. Thursday in Kershaw County, according to his attorney, Bert von Herrmann.

An arraignment is typically the hearing where a defendant, Brandon Strickland, learns the formal charges and enters a plea. Yet von Herrmann told reporters he had not seen an indictment and did not know what Strickland is charged with. He also said he understood Brandon Strickland was not among those indicted by the Horry County grand jury on Wednesday. No prosecutor or court had publicly said which body, if any, returned charges against him.

That gap is itself part of the story. It suggests Brandon Strickland’s case is moving on its own track, separate from the murder case, and it puts the spotlight back where Spivey’s family has kept it for two years: on how the county’s own police handled the investigation.

Who Brandon Strickland is, and why his role matters

Brandon Strickland was not a patrol officer on the fringe of this case. He joined HCPD in 2005 and spent about two decades there. At the time of the shooting, he was a close friend of Boyd and led the bureau that included the department’s criminal investigations unit, the very unit responsible for the Spivey case.

The public first learned the depth of that relationship through Boyd’s own recordings. Records released by the Spivey family through their civil case included calls Boyd kept with police after the shooting. In some of them, Brandon Strickland told Boyd he had contacted the captain over investigations and the solicitor after hearing about the shooting, and he reassured Boyd that he “was taken care of”.

A federal lawsuit filed by Spivey’s family goes further. It alleges that in one call Brandon Strickland told Boyd he was glad the man Boyd shot was white, and it argues the remark reflected worry about public reaction had Spivey been Black. That is an allegation in a civil complaint and has not been proven in court.

Brandon Strickland has denied wrongdoing. He resigned in March 2025. His separation paperwork lists the reason as resignation while under internal investigation and notes he was the subject of both criminal and internal affairs inquiries at the time. His attorney has said Brandon Strickland did not know about a criminal probe when he left and stepped down because rumors made it impossible to lead effectively.

The central question here is not whether two friends talked on the phone. It is whether the official who supervised investigators used that position to shape the outcome of a homicide case. That question now appears headed toward a courtroom, where it will be tested by evidence rather than by press conferences or social media.

To understand how the case reached this point, it helps to trace how a closed self-defense file turned into a murder prosecution.

From “stand your ground” to murder charges

Spivey, 33, of Tabor City, was shot and killed near West Highway 9 and Camp Swamp Road on Sept. 9, 2023. Two days later, a police report relayed the white truck driver’s account that Spivey got out and opened fire first. After Boyd posted on Facebook thanking HCPD and the 15th Circuit Solicitor’s Office for their work, county police brought in the State Law Enforcement Division, and Solicitor Jimmy Richardson handed charging decisions to the Attorney General.

In April 2024, the Attorney General’s Office declined to charge Boyd, citing insufficient evidence. In August 2025, it told SLED it believed the state’s stand-your-ground law applied, while leaving the door open if new material evidence surfaced. Two months later, then-Attorney General Alan Wilson asked 7th Circuit Solicitor Barry Barnette to review both the shooting and the alleged police misconduct.

The turning point came in a civil courtroom. During a four-day immunity hearing in February 2026, Judge Eugene Griffith denied Boyd’s request for stand-your-ground immunity. He denied Williams’ request in a written order on March 6, pointing to conflicting testimony, including over who fired first.

Wednesday’s indictments allege the two men acted together, either as accomplices or by engaging in mutual combat, before killing Spivey. Both maintain they fired in self-defense.

The civil ruling was not a verdict on guilt. But it showed that a judge, after hearing witnesses under oath, did not find the self-defense story settled. That finding undercut the premise on which the case had been closed for two years.

The murder case, however, is only half of what has unfolded. The other half concerns the department itself.

A department under the microscope

Brandon Strickland is not the only HCPD figure whose conduct has drawn scrutiny. The department fired Sgt. Paul “Damon” Vescovi after body-camera footage showed him holding up a note to Boyd and Williams that read “Act like a victim. Camera”. Vescovi has been under a pending criminal investigation, with no charges filed. An internal review also found seven dashcam videos tied to the case had been mishandled and mislabeled, and those were turned over to SLED.

Police Chief Kris Leonhardt asked SLED and the FBI in March 2025 to review evidence in the shooting, and the governor’s office later said it would wait for SLED’s misconduct review before acting on calls for outside oversight. In February 2026, the 7th Circuit Solicitor’s Office confirmed a state grand jury would examine the case.

Then, in September 2026, Jennifer Spivey Foley, representing her brother’s estate, sued Horry County and 13 HCPD officers and supervisors, alleging they mishandled the case and tried to shield Boyd and Williams. Those claims remain unproven.

For Horry County residents, this is where the case stops being someone else’s tragedy. HCPD is funded by county taxpayers, and a federal civil rights suit naming the county and more than a dozen officers carries real financial exposure. More than money, it tests whether residents can trust that a homicide investigation will be handled the same way regardless of who pulled the trigger or whom they know.

What this means for accountability in Horry County

It is important to keep two questions separate, even though they are tangled together. The first is whether Boyd and Williams committed murder. The second is whether anyone inside HCPD improperly influenced the investigation. A jury could answer them differently.

Yet they are linked in a practical way. If prosecutors argue that evidence was mislabeled or witnesses were coached, defense attorneys may in turn attack the reliability of the original investigation. A compromised investigation can make it harder to reach a clear answer about what happened on Camp Swamp Road, in either direction.

The Spivey family’s attorney, Mark Tinsley, acknowledged that an indictment is not a conviction and said the process must now run its course. He also argued that the deepest tragedy is that the family had to fight “the very system that was supposed to investigate his death”.

That sentiment explains why this case has resonated far beyond Tabor City. It was not police, prosecutors or the Attorney General who reopened the questions. It was a grieving sister, her lawyer, civil discovery and persistent local reporting. Everyone named in this story is presumed innocent. But the path this case has taken is a reminder that public records and public pressure are often what move institutions to look again.

What’s next

Several things are worth watching in the coming weeks:

  • Thursday’s hearings. Boyd and Williams are expected at the Kershaw County Courthouse at 2 p.m., the same day and time Strickland’s attorney says he will appear. The specific charges against Strickland, if any are filed, should become public there.
  • Bond and trial schedule. Watch for bond conditions and whether the cases are tried separately or move on a shared timeline.
  • The civil cases. Williams’ attorney said Judge Griffith granted a 180-day stay of the wrongful-death case, though the written order had not been publicly indexed, and it is unclear how the indictments affect it. Foley’s federal suit against the county and officers is also pending.
  • Other officers. Whether the state grand jury’s work produces charges against anyone else connected to the investigation remains an open question.
  • County response. Residents may want to ask County Council and Chief Leonhardt what policies have changed since 2023, particularly around conflicts of interest when investigators know the people involved.

This story will be updated as charges and court records become available.

Further reading

WBTW News13: Grand jury indicts Weldon Boyd, Kenneth Williams on murder charges in Scott Spivey killing (2026)

WMBF News: Brandon Strickland scheduled for arraignment in Kershaw County, attorney says (2026)

WMBF News: Scott Spivey case timeline: From 2023 shooting to Boyd, Williams indictments (2026)

WMBF News: Boyd, Williams indicted on murder charges in Scott Spivey’s death (2026)

WIS News: Attorney says Boyd, Williams indicted on murder charges in Scott Spivey’s death (2026)

Post and Courier: Men who killed Scott Spivey indicted on murder charges in Horry County (2026)

WPDE: Former Horry County deputy police chief expected in court for arraignment Thursday (2026)

WPDE: Grand jury indicts Boyd, Williams for murder in Spivey case (2026)

WBTW News13: Horry County deputy police chief resigns; SLED investigating alleged misconduct (2025)

WBTW News13: McMaster’s office takes wait-and-see approach in Scott Spivey death case (2025)

News, Featured